What BAs Should Know About Feedback Analysis

Most people think they know what they’re good at. They are usually wrong. More often, people know what they’re not good at — and even then more people are wrong than right — Peter F. Drucker

Peter Drucker emphasized the need for professionals to know themselves in order to manage themselves through feedback analysis. To perform effectively, people need to know and understand themselves. Drucker recommended that when you carry out an action or make a decision, you should write down what you expect will happen. After about 9 - 12 months, compare the actual results achieved with what you wrote down (your expectations) and then analyse the situation by asking these questions:

  1. What results are you good at getting?
  2. What abilities are necessary to get the needed results?
  3. What abilities are counterproductive to getting the required results?

Doing this consistently will certainly expose your strengths and weaknesses over time as well as your ability to achieve your objectives as planned. 

In terms of what action to take afterwards, Drucker’s recommendation is to concentrate on putting yourself in situations where your strengths show and improve your strengths, while shunning “intellectual arrogance”. 

I particularly find the concept of feedback analysis quite versatile because it can be applied to one’s professional development as well as the concept of implementing business projects successfully over time. Feedback analysis can give insight into your performance, whether as an individual or as a team.  It’s crucial to understand that while feedback may be received directly from users of our end products or services, it can also be done the “Drucker” style by comparing what a certain project or team was expected to achieve with what it actually achieved.

This is one activity we don’t appear to do naturally as a team — going back to review past projects and comparing actual results with the objectives. With the pace of changes in the business world and the ever-increasing appetite of business users to churn out change requests, one can argue that this is quite understandable. However, it’s important to spend some time evaluating past projects to strengthen the quality of future projects and improve learning among team members.

There are all sorts of formal exercises practised today that include elements of feedback analysis. Examples include post-implementation review, post-implementation assessment, lessons learned etc. These exercises can help to:

  • Understand where your strengths lie
  • Highlight your weaknesses and strengths as a team
  • Highlight which areas of your project or business analysis approach need improvement.

Comparing one’s expectations with the actual outcome is an effective way of learning more about oneself, the team and evaluating the effectiveness of one’s efforts or the team’s efforts over time.